November home sales moved barely above the worst crash readings

Sales moved barely above the worst crash readings in November as the last five months have all registered in the Top 10 of demand weakness.

The acid test of price, closed sales in units, here measured at an annualized-and-adjusted rate, clocked in at 4.68 million units/year in November according to the National Association of Realtors. This sales pace is just 150,000 units/year above the worst crash reading for all of 12 years of data — prior to July 2010 when demand died and went away for the winter (Please see chart below of unit sales and note we are worse off than the 2008 crash.).

November sales are at number eight of 143 observations or in the bottom six percent of all readings.

Informed investors are also locking in on the massive gap between delinquent mortgages and monthly sales  (See chart below of units sales compared to delinquent mortgage units.) — with delinquent units at 13.78 percent of all mortgages outstanding and equal to an unbelievable SIXTEEN times average monthly sales.

A negative forecast may also be reasonable by noting that 33% of sales are distressed. Two-thirds of those distressed sales are foreclosures. And 31% of sales are paid with all cash (and no mortgage debt), the classic strategy of time-tested bottom-feeding investors.

Inventory has tightened to 9.5 months which compares to the record high of 12.5 months in July, but it is still far above the average of 6.3 months (Please see months of inventory below.). The median price is $170,600.

The NAR reports that current affordability is the best, in its opinion, since they started to measure the statistic in 1970. They offer proof by stating that median income of $62,141 requires only 13.6% of earnings to pay the mortgage. Typical mortgage-qualification criteria allows a much higher debt ratio.

Please see below for other new updated charts on inventory in units, sales in units unadjusted, and sales in units sorted from weakest demand to highest demand.


PRINT November sales

Thanks for carrying the story to Business Insider, Implode. For a succinct macro view of the US economy seen through the prism of residential real estate please see 10 Key Charts to See Before You Buy or Sell Your Home.

Michael David White originates mortgages in 50 states.

4 thoughts on “November home sales moved barely above the worst crash readings

  1. Mike

    1. Interest rates rising
    2. Unemployment still high
    3.The cost of gas, juice and groceries is rising.
    4.Taxes rising
    5.Government cutting back on budgets/cutting jobs.
    Houseing prices have to come down to compete with peoples budgets.

  2. joe

    Mike, I am reading an article written In Bloomberg about an expected increase in housing starts for 2011. The result of this will be the shaving of a full percentage point off of the unemployment numbers. I am confused by how your charts illustrate more doom (which makes more sense to me) and the people in Bloomberg, all respected people, see growth. Do you see any possibility of growth for 2011 ?

Comments are closed.